
Filed: 01/11/2026
Confidence: High: the evidence remained after the witness left
Observation
An officer attending the public square encountered a mounted patrol horse making a substantial contribution to the public square. The contribution was delivered without an application, a collection appointment or any visible concern about who would stand in it.
The horse continued walking. The rider continued being above the matter.
At approximately the same time, a reader of the Marathi website opened “घोड्यांच्या ताज्या हालचाली.” expecting fresh bowel movements of horses and found only departmental news. She lodged a complaint that the Office had promised movements and supplied minutes.
The Office accepts that a public information service should not disappoint a reader who has arrived with such specific expectations. The two matters have therefore been consolidated into this report. They were initially consolidated in a folder. The folder has been replaced.
Why does it come out like that?
The Comparative Grass Outcomes Desk has asked why animals eating what appears to be the same lawn produce such different submissions. The cow supplies a flat submission. The sheep supplies several small submissions. The horse supplies an executive hamper of individually formed submissions, apparently prepared for a reception nobody agreed to attend.
The Desk’s opening question, “Why is the horse the only grass-eating animal that does this?”, has not survived its own evidence review. Nobody has established that it is the only one. The word “only” has been retained because removing it would invalidate the title of a funded study.
Its current explanation is that the cow submits in landscape format, the sheep uses bullet points, and the horse insists on a bound volume delivered one chapter at a time. The Research Unit has requested a biological explanation. The Desk has replied that it is funded for comparative administration, not biology.
A proposal to classify the deposits as “field dumplings” was withdrawn when Catering asked whether the meeting was still going ahead. No refreshments will be provided.
Mounted exemption, apparently
The Equal Treatment Desk asked why a police horse may unload in the square while a human proposing the same service would immediately become the subject of a different report.
This question concerns the square in this incident, not a legal determination about anyone else’s pavement. No written exemption has been produced. The mounted liaison officer nevertheless offered four explanations:
- The horse is on duty.
- The horse cannot reasonably dismount.
- The rider is not the producing department.
- Asking the horse to use a public toilet would create a much larger accessibility meeting.
A human volunteer offered to wear a reflective vest, carry a radio and remain on duty throughout. The offer was declined. The vest was returned without comment.
Legal Affairs has provisionally described the distinction as “one law for the mounted, another for the mounting evidence”. It requested a copy of the horse’s operational instructions. The horse provided another original.
Chain of custody
An evidence bag was requested. Procurement asked whether the requirement was for one bag per incident, per horse or per movement. Before this could be resolved, the horse supplied a supplementary submission.
The first officer counted nine items. The second counted eleven. The Research Unit counted no horses but conceded that something had happened. Finance counted the proposed bags and suggested observing the evidence from further away.
Clive Hesketh was invited to assess whether adhesive expertise could assist with containment. He replied that his department was not accepting fresh attachments. Meredith Vale proposed a perimeter fence around the deposit. Dr Penrose asked whether the fence had received a notice.
The Street Cleansing Team removed the material before the Working Group on Removal could establish terms of reference. The Office has recorded this as destruction of an unresolved policy opportunity.
Further findings
- The horse had no rear number plate, frustrating efforts to issue a notice to the correct end.
- The deposits occupied a larger area than the Office’s approved demonstration space. An application for retrospective planning consent has been sent to the pavement.
- A nearby rose bush expressed no opinion. Its evident conflict of interest has been noted.
- The claim that the material was “just grass” was rejected by the Parks Desk, which invited the claimant to try mowing it.
- The horse’s departure was recorded as a fresh movement. The Marathi editor has requested that we stop helping.
Recommended disposition
Amend the incident register to ensure that “fresh movements” now contains at least one fresh movement. Preserve the photographs, the complaint and the distinction between news and something a person has stepped in.
Do not retain a physical sample in the staff fridge. The label “DO NOT EAT — EVIDENCE” has already proved inadequate in incident D2H–IR–021.
For future reports, the Office will distinguish between a horse taking a position and a horse leaving one behind.
